Sel Gider Kum Kalır (The Flood Recedes, the Sand Remains) is a collection of critical texts and essays by the prominent Turkish literary figure Mustafa Kutlu. Published in November 2022 as part of Dergâh Publications' Literary, Cultural, and Art Writings series, the work is 260 pages long. In it, Kutlu conveys his approach to works in the literary environment, the subjective nature of his criticism, and his experience as a reader in a literary language.
Content and Structure
The book is a compilation of the author’s articles published in the journal Benim Dergâh. The texts proceed with evaluations of works in various genres such as poetry, short stories, and novels. In this work, Kutlu discusses his critical practice, presenting both a literary and a reader’s perspective. Each of the texts is shaped by original interpretations, observations on the literary environment, and critical concerns.
Themes and Approaches
- Subjective Criticism: Kutlu emphasizes that his criticism is personal, establishing his approach with the phrase, "I am not a critic; these are the impressions of a reader."
- The Social Dimension of Literature: He argues that a work of literature should be nourished by its environmental conditions, drawing attention to the relationship between the literary environment and the work itself.
- Critical Balance: While not impartial, Kutlu’s articles, which address both positive and negative inclinations, contain an intention to establish balance.
- The Difficulty of Criticism: Kutlu, who describes criticism as a "thankless profession," demonstrates the risks of this practice and its need for originality.
Style and Language
Kutlu's language is sincere and simple, yet his narrative contains multiple layers. The dialogue he establishes with the reader is evident in the texts. He presents his criticism from a non-academic yet culturally profound perspective. The transitions between subtle humor and personal observations in the texts give the writing a dynamic rhythm.
